Limits of The Big 5 Model?

—“Would you say the limits of Big 5 Measurement are a model resolution issue or a fundamental issue?”—George Hobbs

a) there appears to be a correlation between the five/six factors and reward systems. So there may be a biological basis for them.

(b) there is pretty wide consistency with these measures EXCEPT with east asians for whom some of the model does not fit.(As far as I know it’s not just linguistic).

(c) It looks like there are a series of problems with the terms we are using which are a little freudian rather than stated in terms of evolutionary necessity.

(d) we can measure relative intensity (high, medium, low) somewhat reliably at least within culture.

So I think it’s a maturity problem where we are waiting for the Top Down Survey model of psychology to develop commensurability with brain structure, and brain structure to be expressed commensurably with evolutionary history.

Leave a Reply